This water-based product is more of a thin, liquidy lotion than a serum and would only be appropriate for normal to oily or combination skin. Other than that, it's a simple formula that's surprisingly synthetic given the claims this company likes to make, and is bare bones when it comes to beneficial ingredients. There is absolutely nothing in this product that will plump or firm the skin on the eyes, lips, forehead and chest; well, except perhaps for the added menthol.
This contains a potent form of menthol that is irritating for skin and can cause damage. The tingle and swelling that comes from an ingredient like that may make you feel like something is happening, but it's just irritation—there is no benefit to anticipate.
It also contains two forms of formaldehyde-releasing preservatives. In fact this product is overloaded with preservatives most natural lines eschew. While we don't feel it's a negative for your skin, it's just surprising given the staunch advocate for natural Earle claims to be.
Overall, this serum is a decent, albeit ordinary formula and doesn't contain any fragrance.
Oddly enough, you have to pay a lot of money for Earle to put fewer good ingredients in this product and leave out the fragrance. This adds up to $75 an ounce and all you're getting in comparison to the other Earle's products is the ability not to have to put fragrance, synthetic or natural, on your skin. Now why couldn't they do that for all their products that have more interesting formulations?
Remember, you don't need a specially labeled product for the eye, chest, or forehead. There is no research showing those areas need something different than the face when it comes to wrinkles, dry skin, or dark spots. A brilliantly formulated face cream will work around the eyes, too; it doesn't warrant a second product with the label 'eye cream' on it. In terms of your lips, this product isn't emollient enough to keep them from getting chapped.
At night, use this light, oil-free serum after moisturising to help plump and firm skin around the eyes, lips, forehead and décolletage. Gently pat over face and neck, paying special attention to the eye area. Naturally active ingredients include antioxidant grapeseed extract. and soothing echinacea.
Aqua (Water), Glycerin, Propylene Glycol, Panthenol, Sodium Hyaluronate, PPG-1-PEG-9 Lauryl Glycol Ether, Vitis Vinifera (Grape) Seed Extract, Tocopherol (Vitamin E), Echinacea Angustifolia (Echinacea) Root Extract, Glyceryl Acrylate/Acrylic Acid Copolymer, Phenoxyethanol, Methylparaben, Menthyl Lactate, Polysorbate-20, Propylparaben, Butylparaben, Ethylparaben, Cyclopentasiloxane, Cyclotetrasiloxane, Ispbutylparaben, Imidazolidinyl Urea, Diazolidinyl Urea, Dimethiconol.
Strengths: Reasonable prices.
Weaknesses: No sunscreens; jar packaging; products are overly fragranced and contain irritating plant extracts; no reliable products for acne; products for those with rosacea, sensitive skin, and eczema contain irritating fragrant components and perfume.
Liz Earle began her United Kingdom-based cosmetics company in 1995 with her name affixed to the label, Liz Earle Naturally Active Skin Care. Originally located on the Isle of Wright, the company their products were inspired by the natural foliage of this part of the world’s rainy, cold environs.
A prolific writer of more than 30 beauty books along with a background as a beauty journalist and broadcaster, Earle became a diehard believer in all things natural. One of her books even suggests you can beat cellulite with scrubs, creams, and massage oils. We wouldn’t bet on it any more than the allure of all natural holds the answer to having beautiful skin, but even Earle’s products don’t follow that philosophy wholeheartedly as they are not all natural in the least. In fact, you could say they are about as natural as polyester. Labeling the line “naturally active” is a clever play on words; it makes you think the products are natural without really saying they are.
After 15 years of being one of the biggest independent UK-based personal care companies Liz Earle was bought by Avon in 2010. That has certainly changed the face of the company! It’s interesting to point out that despite Avon’s home consultant business model, Liz Earle stopped the home consulting side of their business shortly after joining the fold at Avon.
Business decisions aside, the products are what matter and what’s inside those products matters most. We were first struck by the line’s lack of sunscreens. The company’s convoluted explanation for this is how the weather in the UK doesn’t warrant it (though we’re not sure how that factors into the brand’s U.S. distribution) and also because synthetic sunscreens are bad for skin. None of that is true. Daylight (as in UV light, which is present whether the sun is shining or not) in any amount causes immediate and long-term skin damage. Only a few minutes of unprotected sun exposure a day causes premature aging, though you won’t see these effects until years later. Numerous studies have shown how regular use of sunscreen with all types of active ingredients, including synthetic and mineral, makes skin look significantly younger, longer—and reduces risk of skin cancer.
The company does say mineral sunscreen ingredients are good yet that only shows up in their Daily Eye Repair with an SPF 10 (SPF 15 is considered the minimum by medical and regulatory boards around the world) and it appears this product is only be sold in the U.K. There is no explanation why there aren’t other mineral-based sunscreens in the line.
Although we find the lack of sunscreens a sign of bad (or at least shortsighted) skin care, we are also highly skeptical of skin-care companies that sell bust and neck treatments. Earle’s Superskin Bust & Neck Treatment claims the natural ingredients it contains can plump skin around the bust. Again don’t count on it, but we admit the application description will arouse something! Ironically, the description for the product explains how sun exposure ages skin, but then we’re going back to the lack of sun protection in the line. Now that’s contradictory! Regardless skin on the neck, chest, and face benefit from the same state-of-the-art ingredients and there is not a shred of unbiased research to the contrary.
Despite the reservations mentioned above, there are some interesting formulations in Earle’s line with great price points. But even the better formulas suffer from too much fragrance, dubious and overblown claims, and prevalent use of irritating plant extracts. Oddly enough, the fragrance-free formulations in this product line have some of the more ordinary formulations when it comes to antioxidants or soothing emollients—two categories of ingredients those with sensitive skin really need.
In short, Liz Earle Naturally Active Skin Care is nothing to get all that excited about, whether you’re a fan of natural ingredients or simply want skin care from the U.K.
For more information about Liz Earle, visit www.lizearle.com or call 1-800-515-5911.
The Beautypedia and Paula’s Choice Research teams have one mission: To help you find the best products for your skin, whether they’re from Paula’s Choice or another brand. By combining efforts, we’re able to share scientific research and remain committed to the highest standards based on our decades of experience objectively reviewing thousands upon thousands of skincare and makeup formularies in all price ranges.
Beautypedia cuts through the hype to bring you product insights and recommendations you won’t find anywhere else!