Marc Jacobs Beauty

Highliner Gel Eye Crayon

for $ 25.00
Expert Rating

Expert Reviews

Community Reviews

Brand Overview

This fragrance-free eyeliner, described as "a gel pot eyeliner encased within a crayon," goes on creamy-smooth, without skipping or dragging. The formula allows plenty of time to blend before setting—actually maybe a little too much time (it can transfer or smudge in the meantime). Once it dries down, the result is long-lasting, flake-free, water-resistant wear, (although those with oily skin may still notice a little smudging).

The retractable pencil design offers added convenience with its built-in sharpener that allows you to hone the tip and customize the width of your line. What a thoughtful touch!

The majority of the shades have a metallic/sparkly finish with the exception of one matte black option. We wish there were matte colors for the simple fact that they tend to be more flattering, especially on wrinkly skin. If you don't mind the shiny finish then there are plenty of trendy and classic shades to choose from.

Highliner Gel Eye Crayon's tenacious formula makes it tougher to remove, but if you really want the long-wear, that may be worth the tradeoff for you. For others, though, this eyeliner present a fairly even mix of pros and cons, hence its middle-of-the-road rating.

  • Creamy-gel texture applies smoothly.
  • Flake-free, waterproof formula.
  • Retractable pencil design with built-in sharpener to refine point.
  • Option of classic or trendy shades.
  • Lacks matte options.
  • Tenacious formula is difficult to remove.
  • Longer than average setting time can result in transferring color or smudging.
Jar Packaging: No
Tested on animals: No

Strengths:Silky-smooth Perfection Powder Featherweight Foundation; exceptional bronzer; Brow Tamer Grooming Gel.

Weaknesses: An abundance of mediocre to poor products; issues with faulty packaging; some irritating formulas; several unflattering color choices; terrible eyeliner (Magic Marcer Precision Pen Waterproof Eyeliner).

Marc Jacobs first made his mark (pun intended) as a fashion designer and has now expanded his namesake brand to include fragrance and beauty products. Marc Jacobs Beauty is no doubt instigated by his fashions straight from the runway, but just as couture clothing doesn't always transition well into the real world, nor does Marc Jacobs' attempt at makeup. This color line may be pretty to look at, but the performance tends to be less appealing!

One of the problems facing the line is faulty packaging. Although it looks beautiful, multiple products have issues with leaking or just outright breaking. For a line that is supposed to deliver the utmost quality, you should expect more, especially given the high price point (other designed lines do this kind of thing much better from Givenchy to Giorgio Armani).

The line also has far more unconventional colors that pay homage to Jacobs' philosophy that "there are no rules when it comes to beauty." That may work in the fashion world, but when it comes to what you put on your face on a daily basis, you at least want colors that complement your skin tone. You can still find attractive shades in this line, but you have to do some serious weeding to get there.

The biggest drawback is the potentially irritating ingredients that are found in many of the products. We also feel obligated to mention that the anti-aging claims are significantly overhyped, and that's a major disappointment considering consumers are being asked to pay more for something that doesn't deliver.

On the bright side, it's not all doom and gloom. There are a few good products, and hey, at least their clever names might keep you entertained. We also have to applaud MarcJacobsBeauty.com for disclosing their ingredient lists online (many cosmetics companies still don't do this, despite consumer demand and FDA regulation that makes ingredient disclosure mandatory, at least on the packaging so why not on their website!).

We had high hopes for Marc Jacobs Beauty, especially given the designer's success in the fashion and fragrance worlds, but as is, color us unimpressed. And judging by customer reviews we perused on sites like Sephora.com, many of you feel the same!

For more information about Coty-owned Marc Jacobs Beauty, call 1-888-215-8636 or visit marcjacobsbeauty.com.

Marc Jacobs Beauty is sold at Sephora, Marc Jacobs stores nationwide, and online at marcjacobsbeauty.com.

About the Experts

The Beautypedia team consists of skin care and makeup experts personally trained by the original Cosmetics Cop and best-selling beauty author, Paula Begoun. We’re fascinated by skin care and makeup products and thrilled when they meet or exceed our expectations, but we’re also disappointed when they fail to perform as claimed, are wildly overpriced, or contain ingredients scientific research has proven can hurt skin.

Our mission has always been to help you find the best products for your skin, no matter your budget or preferences. Beautypedia’s thorough and insightful reviews cut through the hype and provide reliable recommendations for all ages, skin types, and skin tones.

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our terms of use here.