Blackhead Eliminating Strip to Scrub
Neutrogena means well with Blackhead Eliminating Strip to Scrub, but the physiologic fact remains that as annoying as blackheads are, they cannot be scrubbed away. Although the concept of a scrub for blackheads isn’t new, the manner in which Neutrogena created this transformative product is; we just wish it was as effective as the claims state!
The brand offers this product in packs of six or fourteen individually-wrapped strips, with the larger quantity costing a few dollars more. Like most “pore strips”, you’re supposed to remove one strip from the pouch, and apply it to clean, damp skin making sure your fingers are dry (applying with wet fingers makes the process messier and causes the opposite side of the strip to disintegrate too soon).
It applies easily, adheres well and feels comfortable for the couple of minutes you let it sit. At the 2-minute mark, you’re directed to wet the area and begin massaging (but not removing) the strip. Doing so causes the strip to morph into a cleansing scrub, a neat feat of chemistry made possible by a clever suspension of polyvinyl alcohol (a plasticizing alcohol often used in peel-off masks) and cellulose, a plant-derived gel-like thickener.
Despite the transformation, the scrub feels progressively more abrasive the longer you massage (and some amount of massaging is necessary to completely remove the strip; merely splashing off with water isn’t enough).
The scrub action is harsh enough to leave skin feeling over-cleansed, to the point of being squeaky-clean, meaning barrier damage has occurred. We weren’t too surprised by this given the main cleansing agent is the thorough-to-the-point-of-being drying sodium C14-16 olefin sulfonate.
If that wasn’t bad enough, the formula contains menthol and menthol derivative menthyl lactate, both capable of irritating skin; you’ll feel their cooling tingle for several minutes after using a strip.
The irony is that the irritation this product causes can stimulate more oil production at the base of the pore, setting the stage for ongoing blackheads.
Last, although these strips are medicated with proven blackhead-dissolver salicylic acid, its contact with skin is too brief for it to have much benefit. You will have much better results using a well formulated leave-on salicylic acid exfoliant than occasional use of a product like this.
- Easy to apply.
- Adheres well to wet skin and doesn’t feel uncomfortable in use.
- Contains two forms of skin irritant menthol, leaving a lingering tingle.
- Salicylic acid needs more than 1-2 minutes of contact with skin to most effectively exfoliate.
- The scrub aspect feels progressively grainier in use.
- Abrasive nature of the scrub makes skin feel squeaky-clean, a sign of barrier damage.
First of its kind! This unique blackhead solution transforms from a blackhead-targeting pore strip into a gentle exfoliating scrub for visibly smaller pores. Its blackhead fighting medicine not only targets blackheads, it keeps them from coming back.
Strengths: Inexpensive; several recommended cleansers; retinol options, in stable packaging; vast selection of sunscreens, most of which offer excellent UVA protection; several fragrance-free options; many of the Healthy Skin products are state-of-the-art; the foundations with sunscreen provide sufficient UVA protection; some praiseworthy makeup items.
Weaknesses: An overabundance of overlapping anti-aging products that is perennially confusing for consumers; irritating bar soaps; lackluster to downright bad toners; a handful of bland moisturizers and eye creams; some sunscreens too much alcohol or problematic preservatives; most of the Deep Clean products are terrible; mostly disappointing concealers; the lip balms with sunscreen provide inadequate UVA protection.
Johnson & Johnsonowned Neutrogena has been around for over 50 years, and they've come a long way since they launched their first transparent, bronze, detergent-based bar soap (it also contains tallow). The bars are still sold, and while we still don't recommend them (they are too drying for all skin types), the good news is that Neutrogena has come a very long way from where they started. In fact, several of their products represent truly state-of-the-art options.
Strolling the skin-care aisles of any drugstore or mass-market store reveals that Neutrogena vies for shelf space and prominence with only one other brand, Procter & Gamble's Olay. For the most part, both companies offer a similar assortment of products, with Olay being slightly more focused on anti-aging products and Neutrogena going for broader appeal, offering a nearly equal amount of antiwrinkle and anti-acne products. Regrettably the latter category presents few viable options.
Where Neutrogena really excels (and has for years) is with water-soluble cleansers, AHAs, retinol, and sunscreen products. Their Healthy Skin lineup offers some beautifully formulated moisturizers with glycolic acid, and the sunscreens offer something for everyone, including some ingenious options for those with oily skin (or anyone who finds the texture of high-SPF products as unappealing as slathering your skin with Crisco).
A recent self-proclaimed advance in sun protection came with Neutrogena's Helioplex complex. It is not the superior breakthrough Neutrogena makes it out to be. It's a good system to keep avobenzone stable for longer, but Helioplex isn't the only way to get the most out of this important UVA sunscreen. If it were, why didn't Neutrogena scrap all of their other sunscreens that don't use Helioplex technology? And why do they still offer a handful of SPF-rated products that leave skin vulnerable to UVA damage? Although they offer a proportionately greater number of sunscreens that provide excellent UVA protection, it's hard to unequivocally deem them a sun-care leader when they still sell inadequate sunscreens.
It's common to see commercials and magazine ads for Neutrogena's plethora of products designed to combat breakouts and blackheads. It's nothing short of amazing that, after all these years, the majority of these products, while well intentioned, still don't get it right. Far too many of them contain irritating ingredients such as alcohol, witch hazel, and menthol, none of which are the least bit helpful for someone struggling with breakouts. If your dermatologist recommends these products for acne without reservation, definitely consider a second opinion! Even Neutrogena's on-the-spot benzoyl peroxide product contains some potentially problematic thickening agents. Despite this, if you choose carefully, there are some great products (including a BHA lotion) that can make a positive difference.
What's most frustrating and, frankly, surprising, is that Neutrogena's enormous assortment of products represents both the best and the worst the cosmetics industry has to offer. Given their worldwide distribution and research capabilities, they really should be offering a consistent range of effective, irritant-free products to address a variety of skin types and conditions. As things stand now, healthy, protected skin is only assured if you know which Neutrogena products to look for and which ones to never put in your shopping cart.
For more information about Neutrogena, owned by Johnson & Johnson, call (800) 582-4048 or visit www.neutrogena.com.
Neutrogena's "beautiful and beneficial" pronouncement is a great tag line, but most of their makeup doesn't live up to that assertion. This line was lacking in several key areas when it first hit store shelves in 1999, and although some things have improved, the number of problematic products is a bit startling. (We are not aware of any cosmetic line that uses menthol or its derivatives as often as Neutrogena.) Each product carries on about the vitamins it contains, yet compared to the leading roles played by cosmetic staples like silicones and thickening agents, the vitamins have mere cameo roles, and as such have little to no impact.
There are a few key items to seek out, especially if you're looking for makeup with excellent sun protection. We also found their lip gloss to be one of the best at any price, and a few of their foundations successfully bridge the gap between skin care and makeup.
The most frustrating aspect of this line is that almost all of it is packaged so you cannot see the color. Even worse, the color swatch on the box is a poor representation, not only of how the color looks in the compact, but also how it looks on your skin. What would truly be beneficial is for Neutrogena to offer more revealing packaging or provide testers or offer trial sizes. Their overall collection and in-store displays aren't nearly as tempting as most other drugstore makeup lines, so in most cases they're relying on their constant magazine and television ads to drive shoppers to explore the world of Neutrogena makeup, or they're relying solely on those who don't mind guessing what color they are really buying. It's obviously working, because despite the problematic elements, this is a line that has survived and is very well distributed.
About the Experts
The Beautypedia team consists of skin care and makeup experts personally trained by the original Cosmetics Cop and best-selling beauty author, Paula Begoun. We’re fascinated by skin care and makeup products and thrilled when they meet or exceed our expectations, but we’re also disappointed when they fail to perform as claimed, are wildly overpriced, or contain ingredients scientific research has proven can hurt skin.
Our mission has always been to help you find the best products for your skin, no matter your budget or preferences. Beautypedia’s thorough and insightful reviews cut through the hype and provide reliable recommendations for all ages, skin types, and skin tones.