When it comes to the risk of irritation, we tend to be more lenient when reviewing scrubs intended for use below the neck. After all, body skin is generally not as sensitive as the skin on the face. But, Geranium Leaf Body Scrub is an all-around failure due to its exceptionally harsh blend of ingredients.
The primary scrub agent is pumice, which is a potent abrasive, and Aesop included bamboo extract as well. This duo would be a passable (albeit barely passable) option for the body if the rest of the formula were loaded with emollients and non-fragrant plant oils to reduce the risk of irritation. Unfortunately, Aesop went in the other direction.
In addition to the rough scrub agents, there is a generous mix of so-called "essential" oils, primarily citrus-derived. While these may smell lovely, citrus oils are potent irritants. In Geranium Leaf Body Scrub, their irritating nature is compounded by the presence of the strong abrasives mentioned above. And circling back to the essential oils—they're essential in name only; to your skin, they're just another source of fragrance it doesn't need.
Given that scrubs are only an extra cleansing step and that they won't help treat issues like discolorations, sun damage, or signs of aging, it's a waste to spend money on a product like this given the strong potential for skin problems. Instead, consider any of the alternatives on our list of the GOOD to BEST Body Scrubs.
An even better idea is to skip the scrub altogether and use a washcloth with a gentle cleanser (not soap) and then apply a well-formulated AHA (like glycolic or lactic acid) or BHA (salicylic acid) leave-on exfoliant afterward. AHA and BHA exfoliants can treat a spectrum of concerns, including red bumps, discolorations, uneven skin tone, and dryness. When well formulated, they also will do their job without exposing your skin to needless irritants. Check out the many recommended picks on our Best Products list.
This stimulating gel-based exfoliant's precise blend of Pumice and Bamboo Stem sloughs away dead surface cells while botanical oils purify and calm skin, imparting a polished outer self no matter how rough the day.
Water (Aqua), Sodium Laureth Sulfate, Pumice, Acrylates Copolymer, Coco-Betaine, Polysorbate 20, Sodium Lauroamphoacetate, Bambusa Vulgaris (Bamboo) Stem Extract, Citrus Aurantium Bergamia (Bergamot ) Fruit Oil, Citrus Nobilis (Mandarin Orange) Peel Oil, Pelargonium Graveolens Extract, Sodium Hydroxide, Methylchloroisothiazolinone, Methylisothiazolinone, d-Limonene, Citronellol, Linalool, Geraniol
Strengths: Some products are packaged to keep their light- and air-sensitive ingredients stable.
Weaknesses:Multiple fragrant ingredients are present in each product reviewed, and this poses a strong risk of irritation; no effective options for treating concerns like acne, brown spots, or rosacea; jar packaging for some of the moisturizers won’t keep the beneficial ingredients stable; overpriced.
Australian brand Aesop bears the same name as the famous Greek storyteller, and their skin-care products certainly emulate the art of storytelling with their formulas and marketing. The question is whether or not you can believe Aesop and their natural-themed skin-care stories, or if it’s mostly fable.
From Aesop’s stripped-down, utilitarian packaging, “earthy” product descriptions, and overall design aesthetic, it’s easy to see why those interested in natural-oriented products are attracted to the Aesop brand. How could skin-care products that seem to be so pure and natural be bad, right? We certainly understand the emotional pull natural products have on many people, but the truth is there are good and bad natural ingredients (snake venom and poison ivy are both natural ingredients, but you wouldn’t want them on your face), just as there are good and bad synthetic ingredients. Going natural without knowing the details of what you’re buying is a recipe for skin problems, not a guarantee of better products.
Refreshingly, compared to many natural-themed lines, Aesop doesn’t rely on scare tactics or outlandish claims. Therefore, you won’t read anything about “toxins” or about made-up claims that all chemicals are bad (because everything is composed of chemicals). Instead, Aesop prefers to rest on the quality of their formulas and oeuvre to do the real selling. Judging by the number of requests we’ve had to review this brand, their less sensationalized approach is working!
With that promising start, it’s disappointing that Aesop chose to include such a generous amount of fragrance and plant-based irritants in many of their products. In fact, there wasn’t a single fragrance-free option in any of the products that we reviewed. (In fact, the box they were shipped in was saturated with fragrance just from the shipping process.) There were a few products with lower amounts of added fragrance—these instances are noted (where applicable)—but there usually were other compelling reasons to avoid any given product in this brand, or at least to consider it cautiously.
Also noteworthy: You will find that much of Aesop’s line, from their cleansers, toners, and moisturizers to their masks and eye treatments, have high-end price tags. While we tend to leave it up to the reader to determine what is or isn’t expensive, there were a few instances where the formulas were so basic that we had to mention the disconnect with the cost—these were truly simple blends of ingredients that in no way justified their cost.
All of the above is a prelude to the most critical downfall of the Aesop products: There are no options that can successfully (and without potential irritation) address the needs of various skin types or skin concerns of many people. Whether you’re struggling with acne, wrinkles, both, or numerous other concerns, from sensitive skin to conditions like rosacea or eczema, you won’t find brilliant products to treat them here. Overall, that means assembling a great skin-care routine with Aesop products just isn’t possible.
Aesop is sold primarily in department stores like Barney’s New York, online, as well as freestanding Aesop stores throughout the United States. Despite their growing distribution, we cannot stress enough how much this line’s products disappoint. Aesop has natural ingredients aplenty—but what good is that when so many of the natural ingredients they chose are of little to no benefit for skin, or are potentially problematic?
For more information about Aesop, visit http://www.aesop.com/usa/
The Beautypedia and Paula’s Choice Research teams have one mission: To help you find the best products for your skin, whether they’re from Paula’s Choice or another brand. By combining efforts, we’re able to share scientific research and remain committed to the highest standards based on our decades of experience objectively reviewing thousands upon thousands of skincare and makeup formularies in all price ranges.
Beautypedia cuts through the hype to bring you product insights and recommendations you won’t find anywhere else!